Today we are talking to Melanie Hilton, organiser
of the New Writers Scheme.
The RNA accepts 250 writers into the scheme each
year and these places are hotly contested. We asked writers, who were either
current members or graduates of the scheme, if they had a question about the
NWS for Melanie.
Thanks for asking me along – it is always a
pleasure to talk about the New Writers Scheme.
I’ve been the NWS Organiser since 2008 (and 2014
will be my last year in the job.) Yes, it definitely has changed over that time
and I think that is largely due to the rapid development of ebook publishing
options and the impact of social media. Members are far more willing to ask
questions and seek advice and they have a far wider field of publishing choices
in front of them.
Two things have changed for the worse – navigating
the Royal Mail requires a PhD in post-ology and punctuation has got much, much
worse, especially the punctuation of speech.
do you match up NWS submissions to the Readers and how many readers are there?
There are about 70 Readers – it
varies slightly from year to year. Without them this Scheme would be impossible
and they make a huge contribution in time and expertise. I match submissions to
Readers who write in the same genre, or have a specific interest or expertise
in that type of book. Obviously Readers will tell me how many submissions they
can take, and dates to avoid, and certainly, up to August, I will avoid sending
someone more than one at a time. I also try to avoid sending work to a Reader
who has read that particular author before so that members receive as wide a
range of viewpoints on their work as possible. However, sometimes either the
Reader, or the author, will request that partnership again and I will discuss
it with both of them first. But in August everything becomes much, much more
difficult with over a hundred typescripts arriving, most of them in the last
fortnight. The Readers who are still able to take them find themselves with
several typescripts on their desks, especially if they read for a genre with
few other Readers in the pool. This is why I nag on about submitting well
before the deadline (not that anyone takes any notice of me…) – I will have a
wider field of Readers to choose from and the Readers are unlikely to have a
queue. But don’t forget, all the Readers are busy professional writers and
deadlines, proofs and revisions can crop up unexpectedly at any time.

Are there
any plans for NWS members to submit via email rather than post?

We’re looking at this, and I’m sure we’ll be doing
it fairly soon, but it isn’t as straightforward as it might seem. Many Readers,
who spend hours at a computer screen as it is, find they are much more
comfortable, and effective, reading ‘hard copy’ and some know they will have to
give up as Readers if we insist on electronic submission. There are other
issues, including security and making notes on typescripts. This will be one
for my successor in 2015 to take forward!
In your experience would you
consider an unfinished but polished submission a better option than a complete
but unedited novel? Do the Readers approach completed and incomplete
manuscripts in the same way?
The answer to this is,
unhelpfully, ‘It depends.’ It is probably easier for a Reader to deal with an
unfinished novel that has been thoroughly revised, provided it has a really
good synopsis so they can see where it is going. A complete but unedited one
will result in them spending a lot of time telling you about points that you
know you’ll have picked up for yourself when you started revising. On the other
hand they’ll see the work in its entirety and be able to judge pace, structure,
the effectiveness of the ending and so forth. The shorter a partial, the harder
it is for the Reader to give you as much help as they would like to, and the greater
the importance of the synopsis. Having said that, we’ve taken partials as short
as one chapter and unfinished novels which consisted largely of chapters of
notes. Always better to submit something than nothing and Readers will approach
a partial just as seriously as they will a complete novel.
How much do you think the NWS influences a writer’s success?
You would have to ask NWS members and
ex-members that! Many, when they tell us about their publishing deal, will say
that they don’t think they’d have made it without the NWS or that they are
certain their Reader’s advice was a great help. This is another of those ‘it
depends’ questions. Some NWS members join when they are on the brink of success
and just need that little extra polish, others have started from scratch and
need quite a bit of help and some, I suspect, may well never have made it on
their own. If nothing else, it helps writers understand the importance of
feedback and the role of the editor.
percentage terms, how many members of the NWS would you say go on to find
publishing deals and how many years on average does it take them to reach that
point? How many give up and drop out?
I can’t give you a definitive answer on publishing
deals because I don’t have statistics for NWS members who become Full members
with a book which doesn’t qualify them for the Joan Hessayon Award. (ie it must
have gone through the NWS in some form and they must have remained in
membership from that time). However, in the time I’ve been Organiser the
numbers for the Joan Hessayon Award are as follows (the year is the year of the
award, so the contracts would have been in the previous year):
2009 – 2; 2010 – 4; 2011 – 5; 2012 – 9; 2013 – 10;
2014 – 17.  We already have 5 contenders
for 2015!
The length of time it takes to secure a deal is
incredibly variable. We have had ‘instant’ successes – but these are often
authors who were already almost there when they joined. We have had members who
have been in the NWS for 10+ years, often not because their writing was not good,
but because they just weren’t the right match for mainstream commercial market
requirements. This is where the greater variety of publishing outlets of recent
years has been so helpful.
As for those ‘giving up’, that is impossible to
say. I know how many don’t renew each year of course, but that can be for a
number of reasons – a change of genre, family pressures, illness and so forth.
The number who feel, ‘I just don’t want to do this anymore,’ is, I suspect,
very low.
With 250 NWS members to coordinate each year I
wondered how much of your time is spent working with these new members and how
do you plan your own writing life around this work?
When September 1st
arrives I will always get emails saying, ‘I’ll bet you’re glad that’s over for
another year!’ at which point I hoot with laughter (or reach for the tissues!)
Most of the year it takes from one to three hours a day. January to July I’m
receiving typescripts and distributing them and dealing with queries, September
through to December is following up outstanding typescripts, answering queries,
organising the Joan Hessayon Award books coming in and working with the
Membership Secretary on the next year’s forms etc. August it is full time and I
will never go on holiday or schedule a deadline then. But it is incredibly
satisfying to be able to help aspiring authors and I know I am going to miss it
when I stop.
How about your own writing,
At the moment I’m working on a book for the
Waterloo anniversary in 2015. It will be part three of a trilogy – the other
authors are RNA members Linda Hooper (Sarah Mallory) and Chris Burrows (Annie
Burrows). I’m also getting my self-published book Walks Through Regency London ready to go up as an ebook and
researching the Georgian seaside for Shire Publications. In January Harlequin
are publishing my 44th historical romance, From Ruin To Riches

Melanie’s website:
Many thanks for taking the time to answer our
questions, Melanie.
Thank you also to Karen
Aldous, Francesca Capaldi Burgess, Natalie Kleinman, Elaine Roberts and Vivien Hampshire for asking such interesting questions.
Compiled by Elaine and
brought to you by the blogging team of Elaine Everest, Natalie Kleinman and Liv
  1. Author
    Natalie Kleinman 4 years ago

    I have just graduated from the NWS, having received a huge amount of help from my Reader and everyone else concerned. Now that I have read your post, Melanie, I am even more in awe of you and those who enable this wonderful scheme. The rest of us only see the little bit on the surface, don't we, and I now fully understand your plea for early submission.

  2. Author
    Laura E. James 4 years ago

    Melanie – thank you, and the readers, for all the hard work. I graduated from the NWS last year, and there is no way I would have achieved publication without the help of the RNA NWS. It's a fantastic scheme, and a wonderful association.
    I wish you well for the future.

  3. Author
    Joan Fleming 4 years ago

    Melanie – a huge thank you once again for all you do for the NWS. Having graduated as recently as December 2013, I'm still in the throws of the excitement of a publication contract. That would not, I'm sure, have happened at this stage without the help and support of the NWS. It's a brilliant scheme, one we're very fortunate to have in the RNA.
    All best wishes for the future.

  4. Author
    Jan Brigden 4 years ago

    This is my third year on the New Writers' Scheme. I'm so thankful I joined, and fully appreciative of all the hard work that goes into the organisation, Melanie. The feedback is invaluable. I've also made so many wonderful, supportive friends. Thank you and all the very best for the future.

  5. Author
    Rosemary Gemmell 4 years ago

    I would probably never have finished my novels nor found a publisher a couple of years ago if not for the NWS – a wonderful scheme. Thanks for all your hard work with it, Melanie.

  6. Author
    Rachael Thomas 4 years ago

    Thank you for all your hard work with NWS. I have been in it for a few years and wouldn't even think of dropping out. With your help and that of the readers I am hoping I will be able to graduate soon. In the meantime, I'm working towards submitting my ms in a few months time.

  7. Author 4 years ago

    Thank you for all your hard work and for the support you gave me when I was in the NWS. My Reader's advice, too, was invaluable – I still get out her notes on increasing internal conflict and re-examine them!It was an eye-opener to hear about how much you have to do behind the scenes. A massive thanks!

  8. Author
    Francesca Capaldi Burgess 4 years ago

    Thank you for that information, Melanie. I knew your job must take up quite a lot of your time but never realised just how much. I count myself lucky to be in the NWS and appreciate all the hard work you and the readers put in. Thank you to you all.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.


©2018 Romantic Novelists' Association

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?